arrow_backBack to Projects
Project15 messages

Arthur Andersen / Audit Pressure

Feb 27, 2001 – Jan 23, 2002

Updated Jun 5, 2026

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Create a concise project brief from attached messages and citations.

The messages trace Arthur Andersen's shifting role as Enron's auditor—from routine setup through mounting pressure to litigation and document destruction. In early 2001, Andersen provided Enron access to its Accounting Research Manager , and Enron created a confidential folder for secure file-sharing after Andersen lost access to Enron's internal email . Andersen launched an AR/AP reconciliation project in May and a power audit follow-up meeting was set for June . By October, Andersen had signed off on initial Raptor hedge valuations , even as Enron staff circulated news of the SEC's $7 million settlement with Andersen over Waste Management audits . As bankruptcy loomed, Andersen issued a sweeping document request targeting employees including Fastow and Glisan ; days later, both Enron and Andersen were named in securities class actions . Enron's European subsidiary chose to retain Andersen for 2001 despite the conflict . By January 2002, an Andersen partner cited a "large pile of documents to shred" and Congress published Andersen memos online .

Phase I: Setting Up the Audit Framework (Feb–Jun 2001)

Feb–Jun 2001
In February 2001, Arthur Andersen provided Enron's Rod Hayslett with access to its Accounting Research Manager database for a full year . By April, Enron's Beth Apollo established a secured folder on the corporate O drive for confidential information exchange, citing concerns about transmitting sensitive trading data via Andersen's external email after the firm lost access to Enron's internal system . Andersen auditor Jennifer Stevenson launched an Accounts Receivable/Accounts Payable Reconciliation Project in May, contacting Enron staff to discuss the statute of limitations on balances . A Power Audit follow-up meeting with multiple Andersen representatives was scheduled for June .

Phase II: Andersen's Role in Raptor and Rising Scrutiny (Oct 2001)

Oct 2001
In early October 2001, Gordon Mckillop confirmed that Arthur Andersen had signed off on the initial valuations for assets hedged in Enron's Raptor structure, alongside the business units and RAC . Simultaneously, Enron communications staff forwarded a news article detailing the SEC's $7 million fraud settlement with Andersen over false audit reports for Waste Management . Vance Meyer recalled that employees had raised questions about Andersen's practices at company forums and the annual shareholder meeting, and suggested preparing Q&A responses about Andersen's role in Enron's financial structures .

Phase III: Collapse, Litigation, and Document Destruction (Nov 2001–Jan 2002)

Nov 2001–Jan 2002
On November 1, 2001, Andersen was performing 'comfort' tests on TW and NNG pipeline financings . On November 15, Andersen's Richard Sibery requested emails, network folders, and office contents for over a dozen Enron employees including Andrew Fastow, Ben Glisan, Jeff Skilling, and Sherron Watkins . The next day, a securities class action named Enron, Ken Lay, Jeff Skilling, Andy Fastow, and Arthur Andersen as defendants . Despite the unfolding conflict, Enron's European subsidiary ENS decided to retain Andersen for the 2001 audit, citing the firm's existing knowledge of complex issues . On January 9, 2002, Andersen partner Randy Kruger declined a lunch invitation citing a 'large pile of documents to shred' . By January 24, the House Energy and Commerce Committee had published Andersen memos online .

CURRENT STATUS & UNDERSTANDING

By late January 2002, Arthur Andersen faced converging pressures: it had been named in securities class actions alongside Enron executives , the House Energy and Commerce Committee had begun publishing Andersen's internal memos , and an Andersen partner had remarked about large-scale document shredding . Enron's European subsidiary ENS had elected to retain Andersen for the 2001 audit despite these conflicts, citing Andersen's existing knowledge of complex accounting issues . The shredding reference and the congressional document release mark the transition from accumulated audit pressure to external investigation, though the full extent of Andersen's document-retention practices and its exposure to criminal referral were still unfolding at that time.

FRICTION POINTS & DELAYS

warning
Confidential information security gap — After Andersen lost access to Enron's internal email, Enron staff grew concerned about sending sensitive trading data (positions, curves, stress tests) via Andersen's external email and implemented a restricted shared drive folder to mitigate exposure .
warning
Sweeping document request amid collapse — On November 15, 2001, Andersen requested emails, network folders, laptops, and office contents for over a dozen Enron employees tied to LJM and Raptor transactions, creating tension between the audit firm and its client at a moment of extreme vulnerability .
warning
Document shredding remark — On January 9, 2002, Andersen partner Randy Kruger postponed a lunch by stating he had 'too large a pile of documents to shred,' a remark that later became evidence in the firm's obstruction-of-justice proceedings .
search
Filter by Sender:

1Setting Up the Audit Framework (Feb–Jun 2001)

Feb–Jun 2001

In February 2001, Arthur Andersen provided Enron's Rod Hayslett with access to its Accounting Research Manager database for a full year [msg:162960]. By April, Enron's Beth Apollo established a secured folder on the corporate O drive for confidential information exchange, citing concerns about transmitting sensitive trading data via Andersen's external email after the firm lost access to Enron's internal system [msg:24817]. Andersen auditor Jennifer Stevenson launched an Accounts Receivable/Accounts Payable Reconciliation Project in May, contacting Enron staff to discuss the statute of limitations on balances [msg:385699]. A Power Audit follow-up meeting with multiple Andersen representatives was scheduled for June [msg:503886][msg:506382].

InboundEmail #162960
Feb 27, 2001

Accounting Research Manager User ID

From: James K Hemore

ja***@us.arthurandersen.com

VantageSource Date: 02/28/2001 01:08 PM From: James K. Hemore , 800-872-2454 Welcome to Arthur Andersen's U.S. Accounting Research Manager. You now have full access to this comprehensive database for a full year. We are...

InboundEmail #24817
Apr 9, 2001

Confidential Folder to safely pass information to Arthur Andersen

From: Beth Apollo

be***@enron.com

We have become increasingly concerned about confidential information (dpr/position info, curves, validations/stress tests, etc) being passed to Arthur Andersen for audit purposes over the Web to their Arthur Andersen ema...

InboundEmail #385699
May 10, 2001

Arthur Andersen Audit

From: Jennifer Stevenson

je***@us.andersen.com

objectives of the Accounts Receivable/Accounts Payable Reconciliation Project that will be conducted by Arthur Andersen. If you are not aware of the review or have not been contacted by myself , I will be contacting you...

InboundEmail #506382
Jun 25, 2001

Arthur Andersen audit starts

From: Stacey White

st***@enron.com

Description: Arthur Andersen audit starts Date: 9/11/2000 Time: 8:00 AM (Central Standard Time) Chairperson: Stacey W White Detailed Description:

InboundEmail #503886
Jun 25, 2001

EB 3127 - Power Audit Follow-up Meeting with Arthur Andersen (Jennifer Staton, Jennifer Muse, Tatiana Waxler, and Mark Meador)

From: Rumaldo Lopez

ru***@enron.com

Conf Rm per Lisa Shoemake 3-9194

2Andersen's Role in Raptor and Rising Scrutiny (Oct 2001)

Oct 2001

In early October 2001, Gordon Mckillop confirmed that Arthur Andersen had signed off on the initial valuations for assets hedged in Enron's Raptor structure, alongside the business units and RAC [msg:38320]. Simultaneously, Enron communications staff forwarded a news article detailing the SEC's $7 million fraud settlement with Andersen over false audit reports for Waste Management [msg:243980]. Vance Meyer recalled that employees had raised questions about Andersen's practices at company forums and the annual shareholder meeting, and suggested preparing Q&A responses about Andersen's role in Enron's financial structures [msg:244464][msg:244197].

InboundEmail #38320
Oct 8, 2001

RE: Raptor Debris

From: Gordon Mckillop

go***@enron.com

The quarterly valuations for the assets hedged in the Raptor structure were valued through the normal quarterly revaluation process. The business units, RAC and Arthur Andersen all signed off on the initial valuations fo...

InboundEmail #243980
Oct 19, 2001

Arthur Andersen Issue

From: Karen Denne

ka***@enron.com

Business; Financial Desk SEC Examining 40 Large Firms for Accounting Fraud NEIL ROLAND BLOOMBERG NEWS 07/07/2001 Los Angeles Times Home Edition C-3 Copyright 2001 / The Times Mirror Company WASHINGTON -- The Securities a...

InboundEmail #244464
Oct 20, 2001

RE: Arthur Andersen Issue

From: Vance Meyer

va***@enron.com

Also, I seem to remember in some employee forum -- maybe an eSpeak or the all-employee meeting -- where an employee raised the question of Arthur Anderson's practices and maybe something about their handling of financial...

InboundEmail #244197
Oct 20, 2001

RE: Arthur Andersen Issue

From: Vance Meyer

va***@enron.com

Vance -----Original Message----- From: Denne, Karen Sent: Sat 10/20/2001 6:51 PM To: Kean, Steven J.; Palmer, Mark A. (PR) Cc: Denne, Karen; Meyer, Vance Subject: Arthur Andersen Issue This is the issue of concern Vance...

3Collapse, Litigation, and Document Destruction (Nov 2001–Jan 2002)

Nov 2001–Jan 2002

On November 1, 2001, Andersen was performing 'comfort' tests on TW and NNG pipeline financings [msg:163596]. On November 15, Andersen's Richard Sibery requested emails, network folders, and office contents for over a dozen Enron employees including Andrew Fastow, Ben Glisan, Jeff Skilling, and Sherron Watkins [msg:396201]. The next day, a securities class action named Enron, Ken Lay, Jeff Skilling, Andy Fastow, and Arthur Andersen as defendants [msg:38322]. Despite the unfolding conflict, Enron's European subsidiary ENS decided to retain Andersen for the 2001 audit, citing the firm's existing knowledge of complex issues [msg:92336]. On January 9, 2002, Andersen partner Randy Kruger declined a lunch invitation citing a 'large pile of documents to shred' [msg:139149]. By January 24, the House Energy and Commerce Committee had published Andersen memos online [msg:225867].

InboundEmail #163596
Oct 31, 2001

FW: TW, NNG financings - Andersen Review

From: Rod Hayslett

ro***@enron.com

Original Message----- From: Saunders, James Sent: Wednesday, October 31, 2001 6:32 PM To: Saunders, James; Chandler, Bob; Cobb Jr., John; Sutton, Lisa; Wiederholt, Patricia; Jolibois, Anne; Bayles, Timothy; Carriere, Fra...

InboundEmail #396201
Nov 14, 2001

Document and Electronic File Request

From: Richard A Sibery

ri***@us.andersen.com

Thanks for meeting with Paul and I yesterday. As we discussed, I e-mailed an initial request on 11/8 to Jenny Rub and Cris Sherman. This previous request (with some additions) is as follows: 1. Latest e-mail boxes and ne...

InboundEmail #38322
Nov 15, 2001

Securities Litigation

From:

As you may have become aware, the company received notice yesterday that you have been named as defendants (along with Enron Corp., Ken Lay, Jeff Skilling, Andy Fastow, and Arthur Andersen) in one of the federal securiti...

InboundEmail #92336
Dec 13, 2001

ENS Audit 2001

From: George Lojko

ge***@enron.com

I understand that due to Enron's problems in America and the fact that that Arthur Andersen are getting involved in a dispute over various audit matters as a result of the bankruptcy there may be difficulties in having A...

InboundEmail #139149
Jan 8, 2002

Re: Lunch

From: Randy G Kruger Jr

ra***@us.andersen.com

Next week is better. I suggest Wednesday, Thursday or Friday. To: dg***@enron.com, Randy G. Kruger Jr.@ANDERSEN WO, mi***@andrews-kurth.com, to***@bakernet.com cc: Date: 01/09/2002 10:26 AM From: SSCHROED@us....

InboundEmail #225867
Jan 23, 2002

http://energycommerce.house.gov/107/pubs/andersenmemos.pdf

From: J Kaminski

j.***@enron.com

[Link: energycommerce.house.gov]